ABC News: Two wrongly convicted men granted full-ride scholarships to college
Ohio Innocence Project at UC Law exoneree and staff are in the news
Michael Sutton, 35, and Kenny Phillips, 34, have been granted full scholarships to the University of Akron. It’s a chance to get the education that they were denied when both were wrongfully convicted in 2006 of crimes they had no part of. It cost them 15 years of freedom.
Their story aired on ABC News and News 5 Cleveland.
"It feels like a dream come true," Sutton said to News 5 Cleveland. "This was something I always dreamed about but being locked in prison for so long I didn't think it could happen."
Both men, high school seniors at the time of their incarceration, had gone out on Memorial Day weekend for a night of fun.
On their way back home they got stuck in traffic and witnessed someone in a gold-colored car in front of them lean out and fire at another vehicle. Two people suffered injuries. Police arrested Sutton and his friends and they were charged with multiple counts including attempted murder and assault.
Sutton was planning to attend the University of Akron after graduation; he had a scholarship and wanted to study business. But he and Phillips instead ended up serving 15 years in prison.
Sutton’s case was re-examined by the Ohio Innocence Project at the University of Cincinnati, while Phillips was represented by the Wrongful Conviction Project (WCP) at the Ohio Public Defender Commission. Their initial convictions were overturned and they were freed from jail in May 2021. They were later found not guilty of all charges by a jury in a retrial in September 2022 in Cuyahoga County.
Donald Caster, a professor in the UC College of Law who led the OIP team assisting Sutton, commented on the case in a statement to ABC News.
"This is what happens when police officers get it wrong and refuse to acknowledge their mistake," said Caster in the statement.
"Michael (Sutton) and Kenny (Phillips) were robbed of their early adulthood. Everything that people do in their late teens and twenties — to college, start a career, meet their partner, start a family — has all been delayed for Michael and Kenny. They are remarkable and they will overcome what was taken from them, but they shouldn't have to."
Listen to the interviews on ABC News and News 5 Cleveland.
Featured image at top: Scales of justice. Photo/Unsplash.
Related Stories
WCPO-TV/Channel 9: Ohio Innocence Project at UC takes on possible wrongful conviction case
May 10, 2021
UC's Ohio Innocence Project helped earn freedom for a Cleveland man after more than 14 years in prison. Michael Sutton was one of two men convicted in 2006 as a teenager for the shooting of two people and the attemped shooting of a police officer. He and Kenny Phillips were freed on bond on May 3, 2021.
TIME: What Bill Cosby’s release really says about getting a conviction overturned in America
July 8, 2021
Mark Godsey, a UC Law professor, was one of the experts cited by TIME Magazine for a story on the release of comedian Bill Cosby.
Reuters: Walmart was hit with a $125 million verdict, but the law is on its side
July 30, 2021
Sandra Sperino of the UC College of Law was cited as a source in a story published by Reuters on a decision by a federal jury in Wisconsin to hit Walmart with $125 million in punitive damages for firing a longtime employee with Down Syndrome.
WCPO: Sittenfeld motion to dismiss high bar to meet, says UC law expert
January 4, 2021
Don Caster, an attorney with the University of Cincinnati College of Law and Ohio Innocence Project, says the federal government tends to only take on cases in can win in regards to Cincinnati City Councilman P.G. Sittenfeld's motion to dismiss federal charges against him.
Cincinnati Law Dean appointed to anti-corruption task force
January 27, 2021
Verna Williams, UC College of Law Dean and Nippert Professor of Law, has been appointed to a new nine-member task force in Cincinnati.
Cincinnati Business Courier: Opera, book, film cast light on UC's Ohio Innocence Project
February 8, 2021
A book, opera and film are all helping to shed light on the work done by the Ohio Innocence Project at UC Law. Outside of Cincinnati, the OIP is fast becoming a model for innocence projects around the world.
WHIO: First Black woman elected to Dayton Municipal Court reflects on 42 years behind the bench
February 4, 2021
Alice McCollum, the first woman, and first Black woman, elected to the Dayton Municipal Court, reflects on 42 years of service in the legal profession.
Vox: How school funding can help repair the legacy of segregation
February 17, 2021
Cincinnati Law dean Verna Williams discusses the implications of educational segregation on Black students and students of color.
The Atlantic: The breathtaking ingenuity of incarcerated artists
February 9, 2021
Gillispie was freed thanks to UC's Ohio Innocence Project in December 2011 after serving 20 years in prison for rapes he did not do.
Cleveland.com: Men imprisoned since 2006 get new trial after Cleveland police officers contradict fellow officers’ testimony
March 22, 2021
An appeals court granted a new trial for two men who spent the last 14 years in prison for the shooting of two people and the attempted shooting of a Cleveland police officer. The unanimous decision issued by the 8th District Court of Appeals found that Cleveland police and Cuyahoga County prosecutors denied Kenny Phillips and Michael Sutton a fair trial by failing to tell the men’s defense attorneys that officers gave conflicting statements about the shootings, and not calling them testify at trial. The Ohio Innocence Project represents Sutton. Mark Godsey, director of the Cincinnati-based Ohio Innocence Project, said that attorneys for the men would ask the courts to release the men on bond immediately pending their new trial.