Bloomberg Law: School DEI training appeal poses complex worker speech questions
If an employee believes that the job training they received requires them to support anti-racism theories, does that violate their free-speech rights? Perhaps. A federal appeals court in St. Louis heard arguments last week by two public school workers who believe so. At the heart of the issue is whether an adverse action is needed for government employees to have standing to sue under the First Amendment or whether the infringement alone is sufficient harm are among the main questions. A ruling by the US Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit could provide clarity for public employers and employees elsewhere.
Professor Brad Mank
“There needs to be an adverse act for there to be standing to sue”, Professor Bradford C. Mank of the University of Cincinnati College of Law told Bloomberg Law. Mank was quoted in the article “School DEI Training Appeal Poses Complex Worker Speech Questions”.
If an employee attends training, disagrees with the substance, and the trainer pushes back, “I don’t know if that alone is enough,” he said. Discomfort with training is too broad a test, said Mank, who isn’t involved in this case.
Thomas Berry of the Cato Institute and James V.F. Dickey, an attorney with the Upper Midwest Law Center and the Center for the American Experiment, which is representing the plaintiffs, had a different perspective.
“A First Amendment violation on its own confers standing,” Dickey said in the article. In the employment context, there often is an adverse action or other negative consequence, but that isn’t needed in free-speech cases, he said.
Sometimes the negative consequences of not complying or of speaking out are clear from the context, Berry said. All that’s needed is a fear of punishment and the plaintiffs here feared repercussions “if they continued to be honest about what they believe,” he said.
Read the story in Bloomberg Law.
Lead photo: istockphoto.com; Mank: UC Photography
Related Stories
Achala Vagal, MD, appointed chair of Department of Radiology at UC College of Medicine
July 11, 2025
The UC College of Medicine announces Achala Vagal, MD, as chair of radiology. A national leader in neuroradiology and stroke imaging, Vagal has 20-plus years of experience, advancing research, AI integration, mentorship and patient-centered innovation.
Understanding resistance to targeted therapies in head and neck, breast cancer
July 11, 2025
MSN highlighted University of Cincinnati Cancer Center and Cincinnati Veterans Affairs Medical Center research published in the journal Oncotarget that reviewed current research on why Epidermal Growth Factor Receptor-targeted therapies often fail in breast and head and neck cancers.
What parvovirus is and why it's on the rise
July 10, 2025
An infectious virus common in children is on the rise in the Tristate. The Cincinnati Health Department is warning of a rise in parvovirus in Hamilton County. The illness can present itself as a rash on the cheeks and is often called “slapped cheek” disease but can present more serious concerns in pregnant women. Kara Markham, MD, professor of obstetrics and gynecology at the University of Cincinnati College of Medicine recently appeared on Cincinnati Edition on WVXU to discuss how parvovirus is transmitted, the risk of serious cases and how to prevent it.
While working 3 a.m. shifts, UC engineer wowed baseball's Big 12
July 10, 2025
UC College of Engineering and Applied Science graduate Kerrington Cross was named an All-American and Big 12 Player of the Year while co-oping in chemical engineering at L'oreal.
UC joins international Phase 1 trial testing CAR-T therapy for MS
July 10, 2025
The University of Cincinnati Gardner Neuroscience Institute is a trial site for a multicenter, international Phase 1 trial testing CAR-T cell therapy for patients with multiple sclerosis.
Hoxworth issues urgent call for blood donors
July 9, 2025
Hoxworth Blood Center, University of Cincinnati, is calling on the Greater Cincinnati community to make a lifesaving blood or platelet donation to help local patients in need during the critical summer months.
Inflammation, not symptoms, found to disrupt sleep in IBD patients
July 9, 2025
Impaired sleep architecture in inflammatory bowel disease (IBD) is primarily driven by inflammatory activity rather than symptomatic flares as previously thought, according to a study published in Clinical Gastroenterology and Hepatology. Sleep architecture is the structural organization of a normal sleep cycle, encompassing the progression and distribution of different stages of sleep throughout a typical night’s rest.
Study traces evolutionary origins of an important enzyme complex
July 9, 2025
MSN highlighted University of Cincinnati Cancer Center research published in Nature Communications that traced the evolutionary origins of the PRPS enzyme complex and learned more about how this complex functions and influences cellular biochemistry.
Hoxworth employees help pen latest edition of textbook widely used in field of apheresis technology
July 8, 2025
Hoxworth Blood Center, University of Cincinnati, is proud to share that four apheresis employees are now published authors. Caroline Alquist, MD, Krystol Weidner, Kelly Anstead and Jamie Swafford helped write Principles of Apheresis Technology, Eighth Edition.
Veterans urge mindfulness with fireworks
July 8, 2025
Spectrum News 1 and WCPO coverage of UC Veterans Programs & Services in conjunction with Independence Day. Interviews with UC's program director Terence Harrison and veteran-student Crystal Merino.