Bloomberg Law: School DEI training appeal poses complex worker speech questions
If an employee believes that the job training they received requires them to support anti-racism theories, does that violate their free-speech rights? Perhaps. A federal appeals court in St. Louis heard arguments last week by two public school workers who believe so. At the heart of the issue is whether an adverse action is needed for government employees to have standing to sue under the First Amendment or whether the infringement alone is sufficient harm are among the main questions. A ruling by the US Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit could provide clarity for public employers and employees elsewhere.
Professor Brad Mank
“There needs to be an adverse act for there to be standing to sue”, Professor Bradford C. Mank of the University of Cincinnati College of Law told Bloomberg Law. Mank was quoted in the article “School DEI Training Appeal Poses Complex Worker Speech Questions”.
If an employee attends training, disagrees with the substance, and the trainer pushes back, “I don’t know if that alone is enough,” he said. Discomfort with training is too broad a test, said Mank, who isn’t involved in this case.
Thomas Berry of the Cato Institute and James V.F. Dickey, an attorney with the Upper Midwest Law Center and the Center for the American Experiment, which is representing the plaintiffs, had a different perspective.
“A First Amendment violation on its own confers standing,” Dickey said in the article. In the employment context, there often is an adverse action or other negative consequence, but that isn’t needed in free-speech cases, he said.
Sometimes the negative consequences of not complying or of speaking out are clear from the context, Berry said. All that’s needed is a fear of punishment and the plaintiffs here feared repercussions “if they continued to be honest about what they believe,” he said.
Read the story in Bloomberg Law.
Lead photo: istockphoto.com; Mank: UC Photography
Related Stories
State Department Delegation For Discussion On Foreign Policy
February 18, 2002
In what was billed as the most important delegation of the year in the U.S. Department of State's International Visitor Program, a group of 21 representatives from some of the world's most conflict-ridden regions participated in a special human rights program at the College of Law on Feb. 15
PROFILE: Co-op Winner Seeks New Homes for Reptilian Roomies
November 10, 2002
Co-oping has been nothing but good news for UC Honors-PLUS senior Zach Osborne. It's proving to be not quite as auspicious for the 11 reptiles he keeps as pets.
Bono, Chris Tucker Visit UC To Discuss Africa
December 5, 2002
U2's Bono and comedian-actor Chris Tucker led a delegation from the DATA organization who came to UC to talk about potentially catastrophic problems in Africa.
UC Law Students Release Ohio Death Penalty Study
January 16, 2003
Students from the UC College of Law's Urban Justice Institute released a study of Ohio's death penalty system that argues that serious reform is needed to protect against the possibility of executing an innocent individual.
State Department Forum Features World View on U.S. Policy
January 28, 2003
A global reaction to the latest developments in the U.S. war on terror and other foreign policy developments will be available when 19 visitors on a State Department-sponsored tour of the United States come to the UC College of Law for a forum on Jan. 31.
UC Research Spurs Lawmakers to Propose 14th Amendment Vote
February 4, 2003
Ohio may finally ratify the 14th Amendment, after research from UC's Urban Justice Institute showed that a pair of votes 135 years ago left Ohio's approval in doubt.
Law Alum to Speak on African-Americans in Civil War
February 6, 2003
Bernard Siler, a 1978 graduate of the UC College of Law, will be the featured speaker at the college's 2003 Minorty Law Day program. Siler will talk about his historical interest in the Civil War and the role of African-American soldiers.
PROFILE: The Full Story on Taxes
February 24, 2003
Paul Caron of the UC College of Law has turned his interest in tax policy and better ways to teach it into a new series of legal textbooks for one of the nation's largest legal education publishers.
UC Students' Work Has Ohio on Verge of Historic Vote
February 24, 2003
Ohio legislators are expected this week to confer their approval upon the 14th Amendment, laying to rest historical questions about Ohio's stance on the issue that were raised through research by UC law students.
Spring 2003 Study Abroad at UC
March 3, 2003
Globalization, rather than socialization and sun, will be the priority for more than 220 students heading overseas this spring.