Failure to pass fire levies can lower house values
UC economists find fire protection funding has strong correlation to home prices
Cuts to fire protection funding initially have a larger effect on home prices than crime, school quality or environmental quality, but the short-term decreases don’t persist, University of Cincinnati economists found.
David Brasington, PhD, and Olivier Parent, PhD, professors of economics in UC's Carl H. Lindner College of Business, studied the effects of communities that don’t pass fire protection renewal levies on housing values for a research article that was published in the journal Regional Science and Urban Economics.
Brasington was surprised by how cuts to fire protection funding had a greater effect on housing prices than other factors.
“We were really surprised about it having an effect and the magnitude of the effect, too,” he said. “It was surprising to me, also, because schools get the bulk of funding, and police services are so important.”
The Bearcat rides the front of a fire truck during the Findlay Market Opening Day Parade. Photo/Jay Yocis/UC Marketing + Brand
Olivier Parent, PhD, professor of economics
To study the effects of funding cuts, Brasington and Parent analyzed data of house sales in Ohio between 1995-2006, the most recent time frame that data was available.
They focused on communities that according to the U.S. Census Bureau share similar demographic and economic characteristics. The only discernible difference was that some of them narrowly voted to renew tax levies while others narrowly voted against renewing their levies.
In the year after communities narrowly voted to cut fire protection funding, house prices dropped between 6.7% and 15.1%. That translates to an average decrease in house values of $15,000 while the tax savings for the life of the house is only $1,500.
“Not renewing is kind of a shock to the community,” said Brasington, who added it’s rare for Ohio communities to vote against fire protection levies.
David Brasington, PhD, professor of economics
While housing prices decreased after a failed fire protection levy, Parent and Brasington found the prices returned to their normal levels in those communities within a few years.
“There might be some effect the second year after the vote but then normal levels return,” Brasington said. “You can’t tell a difference in house prices in cities that vote against the tax levies the third year, fourth year or fifth year after the vote. But there’s a temporary blip in house prices.
“Our guess is that a big factor in the drop of house prices initially is fear, fear of increased risk of fire. But what happens in Ohio is every fire department supports the other. If there’s a fire in [one area], the fire departments from [neighboring communities] and anywhere close by send fire trucks to help each other through mutual assistance agreements. The actual protection from fires is good, even if a tax levy fails probably because of these mutual assistance agreements.
“Our guess is people are afraid of the decrease in services at first then after a couple years they realize, ‘Well, there hasn’t been any big change in actual fire protection.’”
The Bearcat with a Cincinnati Fire Department truck. Photo/Ravenna Rutledge/UC Marketing + Brand
The effects of fire protection cuts are the opposite of cuts to park funding, which Brasington previously studied.
Brasington found Ohio communities that vote to renew parks and recreation spending see 13% higher home values three years after the vote than similar communities that voted against the tax renewals. While cuts to park funding initially didn’t have an effect on house prices, the effects grew in the following years.
“The parks and recreation cuts take a while to be noticeable whereas the fire protection failure drops house prices right away but doesn’t persist,” Brasington said. “They’re like the opposite sides of a coin.”
For both parks and fire protection, Brasington said, the studies show that those services matter to residents and are worth the investment.
Featured image at top: The Bearcat with a fire truck. Photo/Ravenna Rutledge/UC Marketing + Brand
Impact Lives Here
The University of Cincinnati is leading public urban universities into a new era of innovation and impact. Our faculty, staff and students are saving lives, changing outcomes and bending the future in our city's direction. Next Lives Here.
Related Stories
Prestigious green and gold accolades highlight UC Earth Day 2021
April 19, 2021
There’s no making light of the ‘Gold’ accolade recently earned by the University of Cincinnati’s Carl H. Lindner College of Business’ new home on campus.
UC’s summer semester offers students short sessions, flexibility
April 12, 2021
Coming into the summertime of 2020, Sumedha Kappagantula was considering ways to make the most her opportunities during what is usually a break from the academic rigor of her traditional school year. As a Biomedical Engineering major in the UC’s College of Engineering and Applied Sciences, Kappagantula is minoring in Chemistry and Biological Sciences, taking classes through the College of Arts and Sciences. She thought summer semester would be a great time to get ahead in her coursework, and move her degree forward.
2021 University Recognition Ceremony honors student achievements
April 13, 2021
The University of Cincinnati recognizes students each year who have made significant service, leadership, and academic contributions to the UC community. These students exemplify the spirit of what it means to be a Bearcat.
UC Day of Giving a success
April 28, 2021
University of Cincinnati Day of Giving’s 24-hour challenge was a tremendous success this year, raising $2,219,197 with 3,232 gifts. The fourth annual UC Day of Giving raised its most money to date with alumni, donors, students, faculty and staff joining together to support UC and UC Health.
'To make him proud was high on her list'
April 1, 2021
Alex Lewis lost her 82-year-old grandfather to Covid-19 just five weeks before her dream school showed up on the front steps of Roger Bacon High School to tell the senior that she has been admitted to the University of Cincinnati College of Nursing as part of a touching Decision Day surprise effort this year.
President picks exceptional talent
April 28, 2021
The University of Cincinnati 2021 Presidential Leadership Medal of Excellence Awards honor six undergraduate scholars for scholarship, leadership, character, service and the ideals of the university. Awardees are spotlighted for exceptional academics, creativity, community service and innovation.
USA Today: As COVID-19 cases and deaths spike in India, 'a sense of alarm and horror' in U.S.
May 27, 2021
Rajan Kamath, a UC associate professor of business, relays concern over the desperate situation in India due to COVID-19.
Arts & Sciences graduate tapped as Mr. Bearcat 2021
June 8, 2021
Chase Morris, a College of Arts and Sciences graduate, is UC's 2021 Mr. Bearcat.
U.S. News top grad school rankings include several UC programs
March 30, 2021
Several graduate school programs at UC improve in latest U.S. News and World Report rankings, including from nursing, medicine, engineering, criminal justice, law and business.
Protect Company Assets by Mitigating Cyber Risks
April 8, 2021
Cyber threats and insurance have become a ubiquitous business issue. Insurance is intended as a vehicle to transfer catastrophic risk to carriers contractually in consideration for premium dollars. There is no coverage area where the risks evolve more rapidly than cyber, and so the insurance must evolve with it.